Commercial roofing: systems, replacement and cost

Built up roof details and assemblies: what each layer is for

A built up roof is not one product, it is a stack of decisions: how many plies, what the base sheet does, how much bitumen goes between each layer, how the surfacing is held and how the plies turn up at a wall. Each one shows up in the bid price.

A built up roof is a membrane assembled on site from alternating layers of bitumen and reinforcing felt, and its details are the places where that stack of layers has to change direction, end, or be interrupted by something. Understanding the assembly is mostly a matter of knowing what each layer is for, because once that is clear the detail at a wall or a drain follows from it.

This matters commercially rather than academically. Two bids for the same built up roof can differ substantially while both describing the roof in a single line, and the difference is almost always in the layer count, the attachment, the bitumen quantities or the way the details are built. None of those are visible on a finished roof.

The assembly from the bottom

Layer What it does What to specify
Deck Carries the load and everything above it Type, condition, whether it is nailable
Vapor retarder Keeps interior moisture out of the insulation Where the climate and use call for one
Insulation Thermal performance and a stable substrate Type, thickness, number of layers, staggered joints
Cover board A sound, uniform surface for the plies Material and thickness, taped or staggered joints
Base sheet Attaches the membrane to what is below Nailed or adhered, and at what pattern
Ply sheets The waterproofing, built in layers How many, and the bitumen rate between each
Surfacing Protects the bitumen from sun and traffic Flood coat and gravel, or a smooth surfacing coat

Built up roofing explained covers how the system behaves once it is in service, and roof insulation covers the two layers under the membrane that decide most of its performance.

Plies, and why the count is not the whole answer

A three ply and a four ply roof differ in more than one sheet. The extra layer adds redundancy, raises the bitumen quantity, changes the lap stagger and alters the thickness at every detail. It is a different assembly, not the same roof with more of it.

What matters alongside the count is the stagger. Plies are laid so that the laps in one layer never coincide with the laps in the layer below, which is what makes a multi ply roof forgiving: a defect in one sheet is still covered by the others. A roof built with coincident laps has the layer count on paper and none of the behaviour.

Types of flat roof membranes puts that redundancy against what a single ply sheet does instead.

The details, in order of how often they fail

  1. Walls and parapets. Flashing plies up the vertical face, over a cant strip, with a specified height and a counterflashing at the top. Roof to wall flashing covers the construction.
  2. Curbs. Every rooftop unit sits on one, and the plies turn up it the same way they turn up a wall.
  3. Drains. A clamping ring, a metal flashing set in bitumen, and the plies stripped in over it. How a roof drain is flashed covers the same problem on a single ply roof.
  4. Perimeter edges. A gravel stop or edge metal set into the plies, with a continuous cleat and no reliance on sealant. Roof edge flashing has the detail.
  5. Penetrations. Pipes and conduits need a formed sleeve rather than a pitch pocket wherever that is possible.

Where built up bids diverge

  • Ply count, and whether a base sheet is counted as one of them
  • Bitumen rate per interply mopping, stated or left unstated
  • Cover board, present in one bid and absent in the other
  • Flashing plies at details, specified by number or left to the crew
  • Surfacing, gravel in a flood coat or a smooth surfacing coat
  • Attachment of the base sheet and insulation, by pattern and density

The roofing bid comparison checklist is the structured way to force those into the same shape before comparing figures.

Where to go next

If you are choosing between a multi ply bituminous roof and something else, commercial roofing systems sets the options side by side. If the existing roof is built up and the question is whether to keep it, roof recover against tear off covers what has to be true before anything goes over the top of it.

Common questions

Is a base sheet the same as a ply sheet?

No. The base sheet is the first layer and its job is attachment, so it is usually heavier and is nailed or adhered to the deck or the insulation. Ply sheets are the waterproofing layers that go on top of it, set in bitumen rather than fixed mechanically.

  • A base sheet attaches the membrane to what is below it
  • Ply sheets build the waterproofing and are set in hot or cold bitumen
  • A base sheet also separates the plies from the substrate
  • Over a nailable deck the base sheet is usually mechanically fixed
  • Over insulation it is adhered, because fasteners defeat the insulation

The distinction matters when reading a bid. A specification calling for a base sheet and three plies is a four layer membrane, and one calling for four plies with no base sheet is a different assembly with a different attachment story. Where two bids differ in price and both say four, this is one of the first places the difference will be hiding.

How much bitumen goes between the plies, and why does it matter?

An interply mopping is a measured application, not a coat of glue, and the quantity is specified by the manufacturer per layer. Too little and the plies are not fully bonded or waterproofed. Too much and the excess stays soft, slides on a slope and bleeds at the laps.

  • Each interply mopping is specified as a weight per unit area
  • Under application leaves voids where water travels between plies
  • Over application causes slippage, bleeding and blistering
  • Bitumen has an application temperature range that has to be held
  • The quantity used should be recorded on site, not estimated later

This is the least visible variable in a built up roof and one of the most consequential, because a finished roof looks identical whether the moppings were right or light. Ask for the manufacturer's specified rate to be written into the scope and for delivery tickets and kettle temperatures to be kept. A contractor who works to the rate will not mind being asked.

Can built up plies be mopped straight onto the deck?

Only onto a substrate the manufacturer accepts, and a bare structural deck rarely qualifies. Steel decks cannot be mopped at all because there is nothing continuous to mop to, and concrete needs to be cured, dry and primed before any bitumen goes near it.

  • Steel decks need insulation and a cover board above them first
  • Concrete must be cured, dry and primed, and moisture tested
  • Wood decks normally take a mechanically fixed base sheet
  • A cover board gives the plies a sound, uniform surface
  • Mopping to an unsuitable substrate is the commonest early failure

The substrate question is worth settling before the membrane is chosen, because it changes the assembly and the price. It is also where recovery projects go wrong: plies mopped over an old surface that was never prepared, or over insulation with no cover board, debond in sheets rather than failing locally. Ask what the plies are being applied to and what proves it is dry.

How many plies does a built up roof need at a wall or a curb?

More than the field, not fewer. A base flashing at a wall or a curb is built from flashing plies carried up the vertical face and returned onto the roof, and the usual arrangement adds at least one extra layer at the detail because that is where the membrane is most stressed.

  • Flashing plies lap onto the field membrane, not under it
  • A cant strip removes the sharp angle the plies would otherwise bridge
  • The vertical height is specified above the finished roof surface
  • A termination bar and counterflashing protect the top edge
  • Each ply is staggered so no two laps sit in the same place

Almost every built up roof leak starts at a detail rather than in the field, and almost every detail failure traces to one of three things: the plies were bridged over a sharp angle with no cant, the vertical height was short, or the top edge was left relying on sealant. All three are visible in a specification before anybody orders material.

What is a flood coat, and how does it differ from an interply mopping?

A flood coat is the final heavy layer of bitumen poured over the finished plies to receive the gravel surfacing. It is applied at a much higher rate than an interply mopping because its job is to embed and hold aggregate, not to bond two sheets together.

  • Interply moppings bond plies and are specified at a lower rate
  • A flood coat is the top layer and takes the aggregate
  • Aggregate has to be set while the flood coat is still hot
  • Gravel protects the bitumen from ultraviolet light and traffic
  • A smooth surfaced built up roof uses a coating instead

Where a roof is finished smooth rather than gravelled, there is no flood coat and the top ply is protected by a surfacing coat instead. That changes the maintenance story more than the construction: a gravelled roof is hard to inspect and hard to repair but very durable underfoot, while a smooth roof is easy to walk and read and needs its surfacing renewed on a cycle.

Get a quote

Three things and we will call you back. No obligation.

Or call (646) 643-3790